“Ohio
ranks 14th in the United States in 2019 for the number of active
criminal human trafficking cases making their way through federal
courts. The state had 12 active cases. Federal prosecutors charged
four new criminal cases, ranking Ohio 9th in the United States for
the number of new criminal human trafficking cases.”
– The
Human Trafficking Institute, “Ohio State Summary”
In recent years, Ohio has
ranked as high as fourth in the nation when it comes to the number of
trafficked people. Between 2014 and 2016, more than 1,000 victims
were identified in the Buckeye State by a University of Cincinnati
study, though Attorney General Dave Yost said the actual number of
trafficking victims is “probably underreported by an order of
magnitude.”
Ohio is a hotbed of human trafficking because of its
significant transient and immigrant population, a steady demand for
sex workers and farm labor, and because it’s connected to other
large states and Canada by several major Interstate highways.
Yost said. “The truth of
what’s going on is there’s almost always a guy with a baseball
bat or a fix of heroin or a knife out in the parking lot or in the
next room.”
He continued: “And
you’ve got no way to tell, when she says ‘yes,’ whether she
means yes or she’s meaning yes because that guy’s going to cut me
if I don’t say yes.”
In January, Yost held the
inaugural Human Trafficking Summit at the Greater Columbus Convention
Center – a summit so that all these groups battling human
trafficking independently can communicate and collaborate on better
solutions to the problem.
Hundreds attended the
event. Before they headed to a day of educational workshops,
attendees were told by Yost that he hoped the summit would help
identify “gaps” in the work being done to stop human
trafficking.”
(Jeremy Pelzer. “Ohio
AG Dave Yost launches human trafficking summit to build ‘freeway to
freedom’ for victims.” Cleveland.com. January 09, 2020.)
Now, in October 2020, Yost
joined federal, state and local law enforcement partners to announce
the success of a statewide anti-human trafficking
operation.
Operation
Autumn Hope, coordinated through AG Yost’s Ohio Organized Crime
Investigations Commission, encompassed more than 50 law enforcement
agencies and non-government partners to break the cycle that fuels
sex trafficking across the state.
The broad-based effort,
carried out in various parts of the state simultaneously, identified
four priorities:
Rescuing victims
of human trafficking and referring them to social services
Recovering missing
and exploited children
Apprehending those
seeking to have sex with a minor
Arresting male
johns seeking to buy sex
“The success of
Operation Autumn Hope is measured not only in the number of arrests
but in the lives that were rescued from this evil,” Yost said.
“Every agency on this team looks for the day when no person is
bought and sold in Ohio. Don’t buy sex in Ohio!”
During
the operation, the Central Ohio Human Trafficking Trask Force,
Columbus PACT Unit and the Cuyahoga County Human Trafficking Task
Force rescued 109 human trafficking victims and referred them to
social services.
Across southern Ohio, 76
missing and exploited children cases were cleared, including 45 by
physical recovery by the U.S. Marshal’s Service. Among those
missing included a 15-year-old girl missing from Cleveland whose
recovery linked her and other possible victims to an individual in
Columbus suspected of human trafficking; a 15-year-old male with two
warrants who is a suspect in multiple shootings and a homicide; and a
14-year-old girl who was reported missing by the Lancaster Police
Department who was recovered in Columbus within six hours of being
reported missing.
“My thanks to all
personnel who have stepped up for this operation,” said Peter C.
Tobin, U.S. Marshal for the Southern District of Ohio. “These are
the same personnel who hunt down violent fugitives every day. I’m
incredibly proud of them and pleased that they were able to apply
those same skills to finding missing children. I know Operation
Autumn Hope has made a difference in a lot of young lives.”
“These predators
shamelessly target the most innocent and defenseless members of our
community,” said Franklin County Sheriff Dallas Baldwin. “Operation
Autumn Hope is sending a loud and clear message: We are watching, we
will catch you, and we will protect our children.”
(“Ohio Attorney
General Dave Yost Announces Success of Statewide Anti-Human
Trafficking Operation - Operation Autumn Hope Provides Hope to
Victims of Sex Trafficking.” News Release, Ohio Attorney General.
October 26, 2020.)
Scioto County Trafficking
Three Women
In March 2020, The Scioto
County Sheriff's Office arrested three women who are accused of
sexually molesting several children between the ages of 3 to
13-years-old. Investigators obtained evidence that multiple children
had been taken to a house in the Wheelersburg area, where they were
traded for drugs and money, according to the press release.
Captain John W. Murphy
said videos and photos were taken of children who were sexually
assaulted by several people.
Arrested was Magan R
Richmond, age 32, Lindeman Rd. Portsmouth Ohio; Tasha Stringer, age
37, of 220 Germany Hollow Road Wheelersburg Ohio; and Kathryn
McMullen, age 36, of 422 Brushy Fork Road South Webster Ohio. All
three women have been charged with 1 count of rape a felony of the
1st degree and are currently being held in the Scioto County jail on
a $100,000 bond and will appear in Portsmouth Municipal Court on
Monday, March 23.
(Falycia Campbell.
“Three women in Scioto County accused of molesting several
children.” ABC 6, Columbus. March 22 2020.)
All three women were
indicted in August on eight counts, outlined as follows:
•
McMullen: four counts of rape, all first-degree felonies; engaging in
a pattern of corrupt activity, a first-degree felony; two counts of
obstructing justice, both second-degree felonies; and compelling
prostitution, a second-degree felony.
• Stringer: four
counts of rape, all first-degree felonies; engaging in a pattern of
corrupt activity, a first-degree felony; two counts of obstructing
justice, both second-degree felonies; and compelling prostitution, a
second-degree felony.
• Richmond: two counts of rape, both
first-degree felonies; engaging in a pattern of corrupt activity, a
first-degree felony; two counts of obstructing justice, both
second-degree felonies; compelling prostitution, a second-degree
felony; and two counts of gross sexual imposition, both third-degree
felonies.
Larry Dean
Porter
In June, 2020, nine people
from Scioto County, including some family members, were indicted on
federal charges connected to a child sex trafficking operation.
Investigators say Larry
Dean Porter, 69, of Wheelersburg, Ohio, allegedly exchanged drugs he
got in Columbus and elsewhere “for sexual access to the children of
drug-addicted mothers.” They say the investigation into Porter and
the alleged activity began in April 2019.
Porter was arrested the
previous March on local charges during a human trafficking sting
conducted by the Jackson County Sheriff’s Office that involved a
victim as young as 7 years old.
Investigators said Porter
would sexually abuse children and documented the abuse on flash
drives. According to information from the U.S. Attorney, “He would
give illegal narcotics to drug-addicted parents in exchange for
sexual access to the minor victims. It is alleged he often instructed
the parents to sexually abuse their own children and recorded it to
use as blackmail.”
Porter also allegedly
tried to get family members and associates to lie under oath and
convince witnesses to lie to law enforcement.
Porter was charged in a
13-count indictment with conspiring to sex traffic children (15 years
up to life in prison), attempting to sex traffic children (15 years
up to life), producing child pornography (15 to 30 years), possessing
child pornography (up to 10 years), conspiring to obstruct a child
sex trafficking investigation (up to 25 years) and conspiring to
witness tamper (up to 20 years).
The following also were
named in the indictments:
Denna Sue Porter, 32, of
Wheelersburg, and Crystal D. Porter, 39, of Columbus. Investigators
say both women were seen digging holes in the ground of property to
conceal evidence, including a memory card containing images of child
pornography allegedly taken in Larry Porter’s bedroom.
Joshua David Aldridge, 36,
of South Webster, Ohio, was charged with conspiring to sex traffic
children and sex trafficking children. He alleged Aldrige transported
minor victims to Porter’s home and received drugs in return.
Charity Ann Rawlins, 41,
of South Webster, Ohio, and Ronnie L. Rawlins, 47, of Oak Hill, Ohio,
are also charged with conspiring to sex traffic children and sex
trafficking children. Court documents say the couple allegedly took a
seven-year-old child to Porter’s home to traffic the child sexually
in exchange for pills on a regular basis. This alleged abuse occurred
a few times per week for up to five years.
(“9 in Scioto County
indicted on federal charges connected to child sex trafficking.”
News Channel 3. Huntington. June 24, 2020.)
Portsmouth's Dark
Secret
A team of investigate
journalists and photographers from The Cincinnati Enquirer,
guided by investigative editors from USA Today, spoke with
over 100 people regarding Portsmouth’s “open secret.” Alongside
arrest records, court documents, and threats of legal action from the
Enquirer’s counsel – against Scioto County to access
public information and hearings – the team revealed the framework
of a sex trafficking scheme that spanned the Midwest.
The article released by
both news publications in late March focuses on the alleged
ringleader, Michael Mearan, 73, a criminal defense attorney who lives
and works across the street from the Scioto County Courthouse. It
links the lawyer to 27 women over twenty years who claim to have
acted as prostitutes under Mearan’s direction. They reported being
given drugs and money to feed their addiction for each sexual
encounter set up by Mearan.
“The
conditions are ripe for human trafficking. You have drug addiction
rampant. You have unemployment. You have poverty. You have a built-in
group of folks who are desperate, maybe hopeless, that could be
preyed upon.”
-- Shane
Tieman, Scioto County Prosecutor
In three years, the
Portsmouth City Health Department reported 120 drug-related
overdoses; the county’s overdose death rate is twice that of the
state.
Michael Mearan
On October 23, 2020, Ohio
Attorney General Dave Yost and Scioto County Prosecutor Shane Tieman
announced the indictment of Portsmouth attorney Michael Mearan on 18
felony counts related to human trafficking spanning 15
years.
Mearan, 74, faces more than 70 years in prison if
convicted.
The charges stem from criminal activity in southern
Ohio that occurred from 2003 to 2018 and involved six victims. They
include:
One count of
engaging in a pattern of corrupt activity (F1)
Three counts of
trafficking in persons (F1)
Five counts of
compelling prostitution (F3)
Nine counts of
promoting prostitution (F4)
Dozens of women reported
that Mearan, a former city councilman, lured them into a world of
prostitution as a way to support their drug habits, and that he would
send them to several locations across the country.
Yost said …
‘We started notifying
them one by one today of the indictment. There were a lot of tears. I
have done plenty of sex cases and testifying in front of a room full
of strangers in public is just an incredibly difficult thing to do.
But every one of these survivors recognized that coming forward
that’s a piece of it and I’m convinced that as hard as it’s
going to be, they’ve got the courage to step forward and tell their
stories.”
The case was investigated
by a human trafficking task force as part of AG Yost’s Organized
Crime Investigations Commission. The task force consisted of
representatives from the Portsmouth Police Department, Department of
Public Safety’s Intelligence Unit and Ohio Investigative Unit, and
the Attorney General’s Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation.
The
case is being prosecuted as part of AG Yost’s Human Trafficking
Initiative and Special Prosecutions Section.
An affidavit – filed
back in August 2015 by a senior special agent with the U.S. Drug
Enforcement Administration – casts Mearan as a central figure in a
drug and sex trafficking ring operating throughout the Midwest.
The agent linked to Mearan
27 women who worked for him as prostitutes, including one who has
been missing since 2013 and another found dead of “multiple
traumas” the same year.
The agent added that
Mearan has been “known to law enforcement” in Portsmouth since
the 1970s and has been indirectly tied to multiple prior FBI
investigations into human trafficking, extortion, violent gangs and
“White Slave Trafficking.”
Besides Mearan, the women
who spoke with The Cincinnati Enquirer collectively named
several well-known individuals from the Portsmouth area who they
alleged had paid to have sex with them. The list includes former
police officers, lawyers, a medical professional, a former high
school football star, businessmen and probation officers.
(James Pilcher, Liz
Dufour, Kate Murphy. “Trapped and trafficked: One town's dark
secret." The Cincinnati
Enquirer. Updated October 23, 2020.)
Ten women previously told
The Enquirer they had
worked as prostitutes for Mearan, with several of the women saying
they had traveled to numerous states to have sex at his behest over
the last two decades. Records show that Mearan had represented six of
the women facing drug charges. The women also told The Enquirer that
Mearan’s operation included some of the most powerful men in Scioto
County as customers and participants.
One said she had slept
with a former police chief for money.
Four women said that a
now-retired Scioto County Common Pleas Court Judge, William T.
Marshall, was associated Mearan.
(A report investigated
claims in a Drug Enforcement Agency affidavit that Mearan has for
years pressured women into prostitution by telling them he could get
lenient sentences from friendly judges. The affidavit also refers to
a Portsmouth judge “in collusion” with Mearan, alleging that
Mearan provided the judge women, according to information “obtained
through numerous interviews, including interviews with former
prostitutes.”)
“Are you serious? I
would never do anything like that,” Marshall told The Enquirer.
(Keith
Griffith. “More than 2,700 cases to be reviewed after former judge
in Ohio 'turned up to work drunk and was possibly involved in
prostitution ring.'” Daily Mail. UK. June 27, 2020.)
As far as his association
with Marshall, Mearan said: “The judge had an alcohol abuse
problem. I took him to Columbus. That’s what a person who cares
about someone does. Forget about his job. I saved his life.”
Marshall retired suddenly
in 2018 after a 16-year career as a common pleas court judge as well
as running the Scioto County Drug Court through his courtroom. He
left the bench just before being suspended from practicing law for
six months by the state’s legal watchdog agency on an unrelated
case – an ethics probe by the state’s Board of Professional
Conduct into a traffic ticket that he tried to fix for his teenage
daughter in 2017.
The complaint states
Marshall began to put pressure on state police in his courtroom. When
attorneys worked out a plea agreement in a case set for a suppression
hearing, Marshall stated he wouldn’t accept it and forced them to
go forward with the hearing, on the basis that it was investigated by
Ohio Highway Patrol.
Ex-judge Marshall said, “Everyone who meets Mearan
likes him. He is always supporting anything in downtown Portsmouth
and he devoted a lot of times on drug court cases, including some he
was not paid for and ones no other attorneys wanted.”
Marshall said he wants to
prove the rumors and allegations are lies. “Everybody in my town
thinks I am some kind of sexaholic. I think the only connection they
can make between Mike and me is drug court. Mike wanted to give his
time. I am not the kind of guy who is going to pay out a criminal
defendant."
Marshall continued …
“He (Mearan) hangs
around with young girls. I’ve seen him with two young girls. He
just likes to be seen with pretty girls, I guess. I don’t know
anything or if he paid them. If I had asked him, if he had done
anything like that, I would have turned him in. A judge is supposed
to turn someone in and Mike’s never told me anything like that. If
I know an attorney is breaking the law in any way I have to contact
the disciplinary council."
Marshall said he never
thought sex trafficking was going on in his county.
“I think it’s awful.
What happens to these girls, they get these little girls or little
boys, that’s what really gets me, and they take them and start
giving them drugs, get them hooked, and take them when they are 16
when they are still pretty and then they are done with them and most
of them just die. They disappear from the face of the earth.”
The Enquirer
published another report outlining other possible sex trafficking and
sexual misconduct by two brothers who worked in the Portsmouth City
Probation Office. The paper ran another story reporting state
investigators were taking a more active role in the sex trafficking
case with Portsmouth police.
(Jennifer Edwards
Baker. “‘None of it is true’: Portsmouth attorney under state
investigation speaks out.” Fox 19 Now. April 05, 2020.)
Mearan sat on William
Marshall's drug court – a specialized docket to address persistent
criminal behaviors. Very interesting, indeed. This drug court was
perhaps much more specialized in purpose than meets the eye.
And,
if you go to Michael Mearan's Facebook
page, he has a post he made defending himself where a hundred
residents of the city posted their love for him and his kindness as a
public servant.
Meanwhile,
Attorney General Yost said this about Mearan on October 23:
"If
Dante were around, he'd invent an eighth circle of hell for this
guy.”