Tuesday, December 28, 2021

Anthony Bourdain -- Lessons In Nourishment


It took us many years of trying before we were finally allowed into Iran, the country with which we probably have the most contentious relationship on Earth. At the time, we thought that perhaps our welcome was an indicator of a new attitude, an opening of a window. But as it turned out, that is probably not the case. The window appeared to slam shut in particularly ugly fashion shortly after our departure.

What we saw, what we came back with, is a deeply confusing story. Because the Iran you see from the inside, once you walk the streets of Tehran, once you meet Iranians, is a very different place than the Iran you know from the news. Nowhere else I’ve been has the disconnect been so extreme between what one sees and feels from the people and what one sees and hears from the government.”

(Anthony Bourdain. “Bourdain's Field Notes: Iran.” Explore Parts Unknown. September 25, 2017.)

I loved Anthony Bourdain and his Travel Channel culinary and cultural adventure program No Reservations. Of course, the episodes were about food … but also about so much more. Above all, thanks to Bourdain, each segment delivered interesting, informative, new perspectives, and often surprising content about the featured destination.

Bourdain (1956-2018) – an American celebrity chef, author, and travel documentarian – starred in these programs focusing on the exploration of international culture, cuisine, and the human condition. The series made Bourdain a global icon for the way he engagingly and thoughtfully explored the cultures and cuisines of lesser-known parts of the world.

Bourdain was a 1978 graduate of The Culinary Institute of America and a veteran of a number of professional kitchens during his career, which included many years spent as an executive chef at Brasserie Les Halles in Manhattan. He first became known for his bestselling book Kitchen Confidential: Adventures in the Culinary Underbelly (2000).

Despite his massive success, Bourdain had a troubled past. During his early years of working in restaurants, he had developed an addiction to heroin and other problems that he later said should have killed him when he was in his 20s. While Bourdain eventually recovered from his heroin addiction, he continued to struggle with his mental health throughout his life.

Bourdain died at age 61 from an apparent suicide in his hotel room in the South of France in June 2018. The 12th and final season of Parts Unknown aired later that year. When America lost Anthony Bourdain, we lost one of our great cultural ambassadors. 

Parts Unknown – Iran

I recently viewed a segment of Parts Unknown during season four (2014) in which Anthony Bourdain visited Iran. In the program, Bourdain said he witnessed an extreme disconnect “between what one sees and feels from the people and what one sees and hears from the government.”

Bourdain was known to show up in a country that many Americans deemed "scary" and show a different side of where he was visiting without diminishing what made that place unique. His skillful handling of these situations made for great documentary television. He seemed to find the best in people as he explored each culture. Bourdain's particular manner and voice lent credence to the authenticity.

As I viewed the Iran episode, it struck me how people can come together and genuinely enjoy each other's company while sharing a simple meal. "You like food and are reasonably nice at the table? You show me hospitality? I will sit down with you and break bread,” Bourdain wrote in 2017.

Bourdain often visited places like Iran – locations that were politically or ethnically divided – and proved time and time again that food is a common denominator that can help bridge those gaps. Speaking to PBS News in 2016, Bourdain said, "Food may not be the answer to world peace, but it's a start. I think food, culture, people and landscape are all absolutely inseparable."

(Aly Walansky. “10 important life lessons Anthony Bourdain taught us through food.” Today. June 07, 2019.)

In the episode, New York native Bourdain shared his appreciation for the “overwhelmingly friendly” greeting he and his crew were met with upon their arrival.

This is not a black-and-white world, as much as people would like to portray it as such. That’s not an apology for anything. I’m just saying that the brief, narrow slice of Iran we give you in this episode of Parts Unknown is only one part of a much deeper, multi-hued, very old and very complicated story,” Bourdain wrote at the time. “Like anything as ancient and as beautiful as the Persian Empire, it’s worth, I think, looking further. But it’s also a place that can warm your heart one day and break it the next.”

This particular segment on Iran is rated by journalist Kaila Yu as one of the fifteen essential episodes of the show. Bourdain and his crew tried for many years to film in Iran, which he calls “a big blank spot on nearly every traveler’s résumé.”

Yu reported he was surprised that the locals welcomed him with open arms in the capital city of Tehran despite their government’s views on the U.S. … as they did in a local bowling alley, where “hijab-wearing women dipped manicured fingers into the bowling balls and joyfully flung them down the lanes.” How does that fit your political view of the Islamic republic?

Yu reports …

Bourdain then joins a family for a traditional stew of fried chicken and pomegranate, where he learns how much Iranians love guests. 'You tend to kill your guests with kindness here,' he says.

After he heads south to Isfahan, the camera pans over thousands seated in prayer against the backdrop of the Imam Mosque. He’s served a home-cooked koofteh sabzi – a Persian-style meatball with an entire boiled egg stuffed inside, sour-cherry rice, and more – by Nazila Noebashari, the owner of Aaran Gallery in Tehran. Here, the guests share that they would love to be seen as humans and not as enemies. One jokes, 'We’re not the axis of evil. Just normal evil like everyone else.'”

(Kaila Yu. “15 Essential Episodes of Parts Unknown.” Vulture. July 20, 2021.)

One sad fact about the episode – the show held an interview to ask about the country with a local journalist – Washington Post correspondent Jason Rezaian. Shortly after the episode aired, Rezaian was arrested and tossed in jail. Bourdain, to his credit, never gave up advocating for him and trying to help. Rezaian eventually got out and thanked Anthony for all he did.

Anthony Bourdain wrote his own monologue for the series. Here are some impressions of Iran straight from Bourdain’s field notes …

One of the reasons this episode is deeply confusing might be because the vibe in Iran, the general feeling of walking down the streets, through the markets, the way we were received everywhere by total strangers and passersby was overwhelmingly friendly. I have said that Iran is the most outgoingly warm, pro-American place we’ve ever shot, and that’s true: In Tehran, in spite of the fact that you are standing in front of a giant, snarling mural that reads “DEATH TO AMERICA!,” we found that you will usually be treated better by strangers — meaning smiles, offers of assistance, curious attempts to engage in limited English, greetings and expressions of general good will — than anywhere in Western Europe. It would be hard to imagine strangers in Germany or France or England, on recognizing you as American, giving you a thumbs up and a smile simply for your nationality. That was overwhelmingly the case in Iran.

At the time we were there, the mood was cautiously hopeful for a time when we, Americans and Iranians, might see more of each other in the near future. Iran, it should be pointed out, is very beautiful. The food is spectacular. Iranians are very proud of their cooking — and for good reason. They are also famously generous hosts.

Iran’s official attitude toward America, its policies, its actions in the region, is a matter of record. How it treats its own citizens with respect to their personal behaviors is also a matter of record. You do not want to be perceived as behaving inappropriately in Iran , as we saw in the video of kids dancing along to the song “Happy.” And what is inappropriate is an ever shifting thing. What the “government” or the president says is OK one day might be deemed dangerous or unacceptable by the clergy or the Basij (the roving unofficial but official religious police) on another — as we came to find out.

I’m going to be careful about what I say here. Even here.

Like I said. Words have consequences.”

(Anthony Bourdain. “Bourdain's Field Notes: Iran.” Explore Parts Unknown. September 25, 2017.)

Conclusion

With his unassuming human approach, Anthony Bourdain found cultural traditions to be experiences that should be treasured. He was a master teacher of this message. In Parts Unknown, he pointed out the many differences in cultures he visited, yet he relished showing us the similarities – the good features we all share as human inhabitants of the planet. And, Bourdain was a great communicator who often used humor and irony to make his points. And, above all, he was a great listener, preferring to understand rather than resist novel thoughts.

I miss new episodes of Parts Unknown. I've watched other shows that employ food to reveal world cultures, but they just aren't the same. Why? The answer is evident to me – they lack the “person” who was the gracious host – Anthony Bourdain. His touch was so personal that you felt as if you were on each trip with him. And, as each segment began, you knew you were in for a great travelogue … and an important lesson in cultural identity taught through the stomach, the heart, and the brain.

The Invention of Cuisine

By Carol Muske-Dukes


Imagine for a moment

the still life of our meals,

meat followed by yellow cheese,

grapes pale against the blue armor of fish.


Imagine a thin woman

before bread was invented,

playing a harp of wheat in the field.

There is a stone, and behind her

the bones of the last killed,

the black bird on her shoulder

that a century later

will fly with trained and murderous intent.


They are not very hungry

because cuisine has not yet been invented.

Nor has falconry,

nor the science of imagination.


All they have is the pure impulse to eat,

which is not enough to keep them alive

and this little moment

before the woman redeems

the sprouted seeds at her feet

and gathers the olives falling from the trees

for her recipes.


Imagine. Out in the fields

this very moment

they are rolling the apples to press,

the lamb turns in a regular aura of smoke.


See, the woman looks once behind her

before picking up the stone,

looks back once at the beasts,

the trees,

that sky

above the white stream

where small creatures live and die

looking upon each other

as food.

Carol Muske-Dukes, “The Invention of Cuisine” from Skylight (New York: Doubleday, 1981). Copyright © 1981 by Carol Muske-Dukes. Reprinted with the permission of the author. Source: An Octave Above Thunder: New and Selected Poems (Doubleday, 1997) 

 


Monday, December 27, 2021

Happy 2022? -- COVID-19 Predictions By Experts

 

Good Riddance, But Now What?

By Ogden Nash (1902-1971)

Come, children, gather round my knee;
Something is about to be.
Tonight’s December thirty-first,
Something is about to burst.
The clock is crouching, dark and small,
Like a time bomb in the hall.
Hark! It’s midnight, children dear.
Duck! Here comes another year.

From Read Me 2: A Poem For Every Day Of The Year

We are just days away from a new year. Now what? What will 2022 bring us in relation to the COVID-19 pandemic? We are all tired of restrictions and safeguards; however, the fact is that in the waning days of 2021, coronavirus cases are being reported at record levels around the world – surpassing even last winter’s devastating peak in some places – as officials grapple with a surge caused by the omicron variant.

Right now, omicron appears to be more transmissible than the delta variant but it also seems to cause less severe disease. We can look on the bright side and carry hope into 2022.

When is the surge going to end? How is it expected to continue to affect us in 2022? This blog entry addresses those questions by looking toward the new year through the predictions of experts.

If we've learned anything in the past 18 months it's that the coronavirus can – and does – surprise us. Many experts say that COVID-19 will have an impact on us for at least the next few years and, possibly, the rest of our lives.

However, read on.

Maybe … just maybe … 2022 will reward our best efforts to end the death and destruction.

The End?

The global pandemic should come to an end next year, according to officials at the World Health Organization.

2022 must be the end of the COVID-19 pandemic,” said WHO Director General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, speaking at the organization’s last planned briefing of the year on the coronavirus.

That “must be the end” comes with conditions though.

Tedros said he believed the pandemic will end next year because, two years into the situation, “we know the virus very well and we have all the tools [to fight it]."

The tools cannot operate themselves. They require people to operate them.

Tedros claims WHO projections show that vaccine supplies should be sufficient to vaccinate the entire global adult population and to give boosters to high-risk populations by the first quarter of 2022.

What issues are left to overcome to end the pandemic? Tedros says …

  1. Implementing all the tools effectively, and

  2. Taking care of equity.

Unless we vaccinated the whole world, I don’t think we can end this pandemic,” he concluded.

(Helen Colis. “WHO forecasts coronavirus pandemic will end in 2022.” Politico. December 22, 2021.)

Meanwhile, the WHO is still monitoring whether disease from Omicron is as severe as previous variants such as Delta. This data is still “uncertain,” said Van Kerkhove.

Dr. Elizabeth McNally is the director of the Center for Genetic Medicine and the Elizabeth J. Ward Professor of Genetic Medicine at the Northwestern Feinberg School of Medicine. She believes 2022 will be the beginning of the endemic phase of the virus – the phase when a disease outbreak is consistently present but limited to a particular region.

McNally says …

"In 2022, we will move more to the endemic phase of SARS-CoV-2 infection, where we continue to learn to live with the virus. Although there are many concerns about new variants, especially Omicron, at this stage it seems like those who are vaccinated and boostered are not likely to become very sick after being exposed to the virus. The greatest risk remains for those who choose to avoid vaccination.

"Since natural immunity from prior infection and immunity from vaccines both wane over time, the overall U.S. population will have a range of protection in 2022. To manage this broad range, I predict we will rely more on antibody testing to help guide patients with underlying medical conditions and inform their need for additional boosters. I suspect we will see a vaccine specific to the Omicron variant.


(Lila Reynolds and Marla Paul. “The year of the endemic phase? 7 predictions for 2022.” Northwestern Now. December 09, 2021.)

McNally predicts consequences for the unvaccinated …

"For those who choose to remain unvaccinated, I doubt the world will get easier for them. The vaccinated are losing their patience with having to take so many steps to protect the unvaccinated. At some point, we may just stop doing so much testing on those who are vaccinated and boostered, and instead just focus resources on better protecting the unvaccinated.

"The newly arriving medications will help reduce need for hospital beds. But moving forward, all attention needs to focus on managing the availability of hospital beds."

Harry Nelson – founder and managing partner of Nelson Hardiman, a healthcare law firm – says, “For the unvaccinated Covid-19 will remain much more of a wildcard. I suspect we will see at least another 100,000 Americans dead in 2022, drawn from the ranks of the unvaccinated.  

 

(Lila Reynolds and Marla Paul. “The year of the endemic phase? 7 predictions for 2022.” Northwestern Now. December 09, 2021.)

Expect a winter wave. Dr. Andrew Noymer, associate professor of population health and disease prevention with the University of California Irvine Program in Public Health, predicts that, “The pandemic in 2022 will have another winter wave, less severe and less deadly than in winter 2020-21, but nonetheless still significant, and, in most places, more concerning than the ‘Delta [variant] wave’ of summer 2021.”

(Edward Segal. “Predicting The Course And Impact Of The Covid Crisis In The New Year.” Forbes. December 08, 2021.)

Jason Hiner, Senior Editorial Director of CNET Advice and former Global Editor in Chief of TechRepublic, looks at tech advancement in the near future. He believes …

Healthcare will never be the same post-pandemic. Expect telehealth to become commonplace now that a lot more people have been exposed to using video calls for health visits. And the COVID-19 vaccine will forever change the way vaccines (and potentially other therapies) are created. It's not unusual for vaccines to take a decade to develop, but these were created in 10 months using genetics and mRNA technology. This could prove to be one of the most important medical breakthroughs of the century.

(Jason Hiner. “5 trends to shake the world in 2022: Predictions for the year ahead.” C/Net Tech. December 26, 2021.)

And, speaking of vaccines and treatments …

Both Pfizer and Merck are working on antiviral medications aimed at reducing the severity of COVID-19 symptoms. The Pfizer option (Paxlovid) appears to be 89% effective at reducing hospitalization and death among those most vulnerable, early data suggest.

While neither drug is authorized or approved by the Food and Drug Administration right now, experts anticipate them being available soon – and say they could play a significant role in our fight against COVID-19.

"It's really exciting to potentially have options for oral therapy that act very early," Dr. Judith Currier, professor of medicine in the UCLA division of infectious diseases, told TODAY. The medications will probably be used mainly in the populations where they'll have the greatest potential benefit for reducing hospitalization, she said, which would include those who are older, those who have underlying health issues and those who are unvaccinated.”

(Sarah Jacoby. “What will life with COVID-19 be like in 2022?” Today. December 17, 2021.)

Will we need additional COVID-19 booster shots in 2022 (and beyond)?

Experts say that depends on how long the protection from the current round of boosters lasts and how well it protects against new variants that might pop up, Dr. Thaddeus Stappenbeck, chair of the department of inflammation and immunity at the Cleveland Clinic Lerner Research Institute, told TODAY.

Initial lab data from Pfizer suggests that its booster is effective against omicron. And, for now, the boosters we have will likely be enough to protect against this new variant, Dr. Anthony Fauci, director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases and chief medical adviser to President Biden, said.

How about schools remaining open in 2022?

"There's an emerging consensus that we just have to keep the schools open, we have to go back to interacting, and that kids are lacking socialization that's really detrimental," Bruce Walker, director of the Ragon Institute of MGH, MIT and Harvard, says. "We have to use other mitigation approaches to try and keep the schools open."

Schools must employ mitigation” … are they listening?

Those mitigation strategies can include many of the same tools we know are effective, such as masks, rapid testing and pediatric vaccines. That might also mean adopting some creative solutions. For instance, some schools now use a "test to stay" protocol that takes advantage of frequent rapid testing.

(Sarah Jacoby. “What will life with COVID-19 be like in 2022?” Today. December 17, 2021.)


What Does "Learning To Live With COVID-19" In 2022 Actually Look Like?

In 2022, experts anticipate that we'll adjust to living with the coronavirus by doing the following:

  1. Leaning on vaccination,

  2. Continuing to mask up in high-risk situations,

  3. Expanding access to rapid testing, and

  4. Introducing new antiviral tools.

Together, these strategies will help us feel more comfortable taking calculated risks.

One way to feel more comfortable is to be certain about our status.

If there’s one major frustration that I’ve had so far, it’s that we are not using rapid tests the way that we need to at the scale that we need to,” says Dr. Taison Bell, assistant professor of medicine in the divisions of infectious diseases and international health and pulmonary and critical care medicine at the University of Virginia. Rapid testing is one of our totally underused mitigation measures.

Help is already here for those needing rapid tests.

The Biden administration recently announced a new plan to reimburse people for at-home rapid tests through their health insurance. For those without insurance, free tests will be available at places in their community, like local health clinics, White House coronavirus response coordinator Jeffrey Zients explained earlier this month.

(Sarah Jacoby. “What will life with COVID-19 be like in 2022?” Today. December 17, 2021.)

Simple strategies work … listen up … the temptation to stop using them can be dangerous and contribute to the “staying power” of the virus.

Masking works – not just in helping to prevent the spread of COVID-19, but likely for the flu and other illnesses as well. "My motto has been, 'If you can see their full face, don't be in their space,' especially when I'm indoors in public," Dr. Bell said. "I still think that's a good strategy."

Although pushing the same preventative measures may sound like a broken-record to the populace by now, those who care and who wish to avoid infection should follow the advice of the experts and do the routine – mask up, social distance, wash hands, and avoid large crowds (especially those with swarms of unmasked or even unvaccinated people).

Of course, more variants are always a possibility. And with that, we’ll need to make sure as many people as possible are vaccinated everywhere in order to prevent new variants anywhere.

With that advice, I'll wish you a Happy New Year.

You may think that I'm being sarcastic, but I'm not. We are weathering a terrible, long storm together, and we should remember the old Friedrich Nietzsche adage: "That which does not kill us makes us stronger.” As we know, suffering is part of life, and much of the suffering we are doing is actually inconvenience. For God's sake, my mother and father endured the Great Depression and World War II. In their honor, I need to shoulder any burden that comes my way.

Noam Shpancer Ph.D. Reminds us that the American culture, “itself born of trauma and imbued with a hopeful can-do ethos, wants to believe this idea (of strength from struggle), finding it self-affirming.”

Yet our human brains can be our worst enemies.

Once we have acquired a certain belief, we tend to see, remember, and report mostly instances and events that support it. This is called confirmation bias – the tendency to interpret observations or data in a manner consistent with previously established beliefs and values. Studies have consistently shown that people uncritically accept evidence that confirms their beliefs, while subjecting disconfirming information to rigorous skeptical evaluation.

It is largely confirmation bias – including social media misinformation, medical distrust among some communities, and the politicization of COVID – that is responsible for vaccine hesitancy and refusal to continue to follow simple health directives.

The Happiest New Year will be made possible by those who continue actively to fight the virus, not to resist health officials' requests to keep up their guards. Concerned citizens will do so in 2022.

To close, 2022 is the Year of the Tiger – the Chinese zodiac sign that is the symbol for strength, exorcising evils, and braveness. I believe those who resist efforts to fight COVID need exorcised from their dangerous confirmation bias. In the United States, once considered the home of the brave but now as famous for clueless anti-vaxxers, those who take precautions are the strongest, as they must carry the burden of others who care nothing about infecting their fellow humans.

Will 2022 see the end of the COVID-19 pandemic? The tigers here are doing everything possible to make that a reality. Other little kittens simply do not care.

In the Time of Pandemic

By Kitty O’Meara

And the people stayed home.
And they read books, and listened, and rested, and
exercised, and made art, and played games, and
learned new ways of being, and were still.

And they listened more deeply. Some meditated, some
prayed, some danced. Some met their shadows. And the
people began to think differently.

And the people healed.

And, in the absence of people living in ignorant,
dangerous, mindless, and heartless ways, the earth
began to heal.

And when the danger passed, and the people joined
together again, they grieved their losses, and made new
choices, and dreamed new images, and created new
ways to live and heal the earth fully, as they had been
healed.


Sunday, December 26, 2021

Innocents Killed By Police Bullets -- Unbearable Tragedies

 

The identity of the 14-year-old girl who was tragically shot and killed by a stray bullet fired by a Los Angeles Police Department officer at a Burlington store in North Hollywood on December 23 was announced by officials on Friday. They also announced the identity of the suspect who initiated the turn of events.

Valentina Orellana-Peralta was in one of the dressing rooms at a Burlington store on Thursday, when a stray bullet that was fired towards an assault suspect passed through the wall and struck her. According to The Los Angeles Times, she was trying on dresses for her quinceañera with her mother.

LAPD officers have shot at least 36 people – 17 of them fatally – in 2021, according to The Los Angeles Times. Those figures mark a dramatic rise in cases where officers shot or killed people in either of the last two years – 27 people were shot and 7 of them killed by LA police in all of 2020. In 2019, officers shot 26 people, killing 12.

In the last week, LA officers have killed four people – including two men in separate incidents on Saturday, the newspaper reported.”

(“LAPD kills Valentina Orellana-Peralta, 14, while shooting at man armed with bicycle lock.” Associated Press. December 24, 2021.)

Officers got to the store, which was crowded with holiday shoppers, shortly before noon Thursday after receiving 911 calls reporting an argument and shots fired, LAPD officials said.

Later, a police report filed by the LAPD declared that the assault suspect – identified as 24-year-old Daniel Elena Lopez – was approached by security within the Burlington store when he began to exhibit unruly behavior, including attacking another customer and breaking a store window – using a heavy duty bike lock.

Authorities who responded to the 9-1-1 calls of gunshots on the scene allegedly approached the suspect as he was attacking the customer, and an officer-involved-shooting ensued. The suspect was shot, and was pronounced dead by a gunshot wound to the chest on the scene shortly after while being evaluated by paramedics.

The Los Angeles Times reported that Elena Lopez has convictions for car theft, carrying a loaded gun in public and carrying a gun as a felon. They also found that he has been convicted of domestic battery and recklessly evading police in a vehicle. He had spent at least two years in state prison.

No guns were found at the scene, despite initial reports of shots fired and the police’s subsequent decision to open fire at the sight of the assault. Investigators said a "steel or metal cable lock, a very heavy lock," found near the suspect may have been used in the assault.

The officer who fired the rounds was placed on paid administrative leave as the investigation is underway.

(CBSLA Staff. “Authorities Identify 14-Year-Old Girl, Suspect Killed In NoHo Shooting On Thursday.” KCAL 9. CBS. Los Angeles. December 24, 2021.)

LAPD Chief of Police Michel Moore spoke with CBSLA reporters on Friday and disclosed that one officer fired three rounds, one of which struck Orellana-Peralta.

In that same interview, Moore said that the goal of their investigation is to be as efficient as possible.

Just 24 hours after this, we’re doing everything we can to gather as much and be as transparent as possible,” Moore said.

He called for the immediate release of body cam footage, store surveillance footage and recordings of all 9-1-1 calls concerning the incident by no later than Monday, a process that normally takes up to 45 days.

More than one of the 9-1-1 calls indicated that a shooting was in progress in the store, even before officers arrived on scene.

In response to the incident, Moore issued a statement on Thursday evening, which stated:

This chaotic incident resulting in the death of an innocent child is tragic and devastating for everyone involved. I am profoundly sorry for the loss of this young girl’s life and I know there are no words that can relieve the unimaginable pain for the family.

My commitment is to conduct a thorough, complete and transparent investigation into the circumstances that led up to this tragedy and provide the family and public with as much information as possible. I have directed the release of the critical incident video by Monday, December 27th, which will include the 9-1-1 calls, radio transmissions, body worn video and any CCTV and other evidence gathered at this preliminary stage.”

(CBSLA Staff. “Authorities Identify 14-Year-Old Girl, Suspect Killed In NoHo Shooting On Thursday.” KCAL 9. CBS. Los Angeles. December 24, 2021.) 

 

Innocents Die In Police Shootings

Police officers in the United States have killed over 1000 civilians each year since 2013. The constitutional landscape that regulates these encounters defaults to the judgments of the reasonable police officer at the time of a civilian encounter based on the officer’s assessment of whether threats to their safety or the safety of others requires deadly force.

As many of these killings have begun to occur under similar circumstances, scholars have renewed a contentious debate on whether police disproportionately use deadly force against African Americans and other nonwhite civilians and whether such killings reflect racial bias.

(Jeffrey A. Fagan and Alexis D. Campbell. “Race and Reasonableness in Police Killings.” Columbia Human Rights Law Review. 2020.)

In the recent past, Chicago has seen a string of multi-million-dollar lawsuits filed by victims caught in the crossfire of police gunfire.

In their training, Chicago police officers are presented with scenarios in which they're confronted by dangerous individuals while other people are nearby. The goal is to eliminate the threat while keeping bystanders safe.

According to the Chicago police general orders, officers are not allowed to fire into crowds, fire warning shots or fire into buildings or through doors, windows or other openings when the person being targeted isn't visible. They're also prohibited from shooting people trying to kill themselves or firing at a moving vehicle when the vehicle is the only weapon being used against the cop.

David Klinger, an expert on police use of force, said officers being trained for shootings must take into account people standing behind the person they're targeting, as well as others to the side or in front of the suspect. Klinger said officers must practice what he calls "subject discrimination," getting an idea of who is the likely innocent bystander and who is the likely suspect when pulling up to a scene.

(Jeremy Gorner and Annie Sweeney. “Chicago police trained to not shoot innocent people, but it still happens.” Chicago Tribune. December 29, 2015.)

However, shootings that kill innocents still occur.

One such case happened in December 2016 and involved a 55-year old grandmother – Bettie Jones – who was killed by a police officer’s bullet intended for another person. The police officer fired eight shots at a suspect and one bullet hit the woman in the chest. Interim police Superintendent John Escalante quickly acknowledged the shooting was an accidental misfire by an officer aiming at a 19-year-old student who police said had a baseball bat and was being combative.

(Jeremy Gorner and Annie Sweeney. “Chicago police trained to not shoot innocent people, but it still happens.” Chicago Tribune. December 29, 2015.)

Chicago Police spokesman Anthony Guglielmi said the department does not keep track of innocent bystanders shot by police officers.

In New York City on May 19, 2016, NYPD statistics and reports revealed that at least 22 bystanders had been hit by stray bullets in police-involved shootings in the city since 2010.

(Ben Fractenberg. “Nearly Two Dozen Bystanders Struck in Police Shootings Since 2010: NYPD.” DNA Info. May 19, 2016.)

In one incident in August 2012, officers injured nine innocent bystanders at the Empire State Building when they opened fire on a criminal suspect with a gun. Some of the injury victims filed lawsuits against New York City, but the city has not offered any settlements.

According to the New York Times, the state’s highest court supports police officers’ rights to make split-second decisions that may include the use of deadly force. When police shootings occur and innocent people are injured or killed, the court assumes that such collateral damage is unavoidable.

BuzzFeed News, in an investigation published in August 2021, reported on several similar cases around the country. Often in these cases, prosecutors invoked the so-called felony murder rule, which in some states allows for murder charges against someone who committed a felony that resulted in death, even if the person had no intent of killing someone.

In at least 13 states, liability for deaths under the felony murder rule is extended even further: A person can be tried for the fatal actions of a third party, such as a police officer, if the death is deemed a reasonably foreseeable outcome of the crime.

Since 2010, at least 22 people nationwide have been charged with felony murder for deaths directly caused by police, according to a BuzzFeed News review. At least 13 have been convicted.

Charging the co-felons in these cases all too often provides police officers with cover in cases where the shootings are in violation of departmental policies or are otherwise unjustified,” said Steve Drizin, a professor at Northwestern University’s law school. “The laws are used to justify decisions not to discipline police officers.”

(Emily Wilder. “A Police Officer Killed Jacob Harris, But His Unarmed Friends Were Charged With His Murder.” BuzzFeed News. August 24, 2021.)

The results of a joint research project were published in The Washington Post on April 12, 2015, and The Washington Post was awarded the 2016 Pulitzer Prize for National Reporting, in part, for this project. The Police Integrity Research Group at Bowling Green State University continues to keep the information current, and new cases are added periodically to the count of officers charged with murder or manslaughter resulting from an on-duty shooting.

(Philip M. Stinson, Sr. & Chloe A. Wentzlof. “On-Duty Shootings: Police Officers Charged with Murder or Manslaughter, 2005-2019.” Research Brief One-Sheet – No. 9. Criminal Justice Faculty Publications. 2019.)

Findings of the study …

“Since the beginning of 2005 (through June 24, 2019), there have been 104 nonfederal sworn law enforcement officers with the general powers of arrest (e.g., police officers, deputy sheriffs, state troopers, etc.) who have been arrested for murder or manslaughter resulting from an on-duty shooting where the officer shot and killed someone at incidents throughout the United States. Of those 104 officers, to date only 35 have been convicted of a crime resulting from the on-duty shooting (15 by guilty plea, 20 by jury trial, and none convicted by a bench trial).

“In the cases where an officer has been convicted, it is often for a lesser offense. Only 4 officers have been convicted of murder (there were four officers whose murder convictions were overturned, but the officers were later convicted of federal crimes arising out of the same incident). The 4 officers convicted of murder received incarceration sentences that ranged from 81 months to 192 months in prison, with an average length prison sentence of 150.75 months.

As to the other officers, 9 were convicted of manslaughter, 4 were convicted of voluntary manslaughter, 5 were convicted of involuntary manslaughter, 2 were convicted of official misconduct, 2 were convicted of reckless homicide, 3 were convicted of negligent homicide, 5 were convicted of federal criminal deprivation of civil rights (including the four officers whose murder convictions were overturned), and one was convicted of reckless discharge of a firearm. The 18 officers convicted of manslaughter received incarceration sentences that ranged from zero months to 480 months in prison, with an average sentence of 78.5 months in prison.

“The criminal cases for 45 of the officers ended in a non -conviction: 23 were acquitted at a jury trial, 9 were acquitted at a bench t rial, 4 were dismissed by a judge, 7 were dismissed by a prosecutor, one received a deferred adjudication, and in one instance no true bill was returned from a grand jury.” 

(Philip M. Stinson, Sr. & Chloe A. Wentzlof. “On-Duty Shootings: Police Officers Charged with Murder or Manslaughter, 2005-2019.” Research Brief One-Sheet – No. 9. Criminal Justice Faculty Publications. 2019.) 

What To Do

Yes, we all know the peril police officers face each day. They are a group of dedicated public servants essential to the peace and welfare of our communities. “Blue lives matter” as avid supporters are bound to say. We must not condemn the brave police who keep us safe every day. Yet, when a problem is identified, we must encourage reform to insure undue death and destruction do not occur.

David A. Clinger Ph.D. is a Professor of Criminology and Criminal Justice at the University of Missouri-St. Louis and Senior Fellow at the Police Foundation in Washington, DC. He has conducted three federally-funded research projects dealing with the use of force by police officers; two on officer-involved shootings and one on police special weapons and tactics (SWAT) teams.

As an officer in south-central Los Angeles, Clinger once had to shoot and kill an assailant who had stabbed his police partner. This incident became a deadly shooting that turned the Clinger into a researcher seeking to understand the dynamics of confrontation – one who hopes to be a voice of reason in an emotional national debate, and an advocate for change.

Clinger says …

If we are to bridge, or at least narrow, this divide and thereby ease the public’s disquiet, I believe we must learn to think about the phenomenon of police shootings from a fresh frame of reference. We must find a standpoint that permits us to move past the passion-laden medium of morality and towards a deeper understanding of the social reality of deadly force in our society.

Such a move might well serve to enlighten police critics and other concerned citizens about the nature of police work, the dangers officers face, how this influences their attitudes and actions, and what we can realistically expect police to do when confronted with life-and-death situations. Such enlightenment could, in turn, help the public, critics included, to see that lethal force is sometimes unavoidable; that police officers must sometimes kill people to protect themselves and other innocents from harm.

“A move away from the moral plane might also help remind police and their supporters that democratic policing requires restraint and forbearance on the part of those who carry a badge and gun. This, in turn, might help officers deal with citizens in ways that minimize the odds that gunfire will erupt, for extensive evidence indicates that how the
police structure their interaction with citizens can have a marked effect on the likelihood of violence.

In-depth case studies, practical experience, and empirical research have demonstrated that police will need to use deadly force less frequently if they adhere to a few simple, tactical principles. James Fyfe, for example, has written and spoken extensively during the past quarter century about how officers can use the principles of tactical knowledge and concealment to reduce the likelihood of having to resort to deadly force when handling potentially dangerous situations (Fyfe 2001; Scharf and Binder 1983).”

(David Clinger. “Social Theory and the Street Cop: The Case of Deadly Force.” Police Foundation Number 7. June 2005.)

Clinger advocates for the principle of tactical knowledge – that view holds that officers should develop as much information as they can about each potentially violent situation they are called upon to handle before committing themselves to a particular course of action. As a result, officers need not shoot when potential threats fail to materialize, and they may have enough time to decide how to resolve those situations that do involve danger without resorting to gunfire.

Testifying at a U.S. Civil Rights Commission hearing on deadly force, one topic Clinger discussed was "tactical positioning," a strategy in which officers keep a safe distance, unless there is imminent danger.

"Often times, officers find themselves in too close, too quickly, and they don't have any option other than to shoot their way out of it," Klinger says. "That's where I really think we fall down in American law enforcement."

Maria Haberfeld, a John Jay College professor who researches police use of force, spoke of New York and said that currently recruits must be at least 21 years old on or before their date of hire. Haberfeld believes that instituting an older age requirement of 25 for NYPD recruits could help officers handle intense situations because, "(You have) emotional maturity at an older age."

Haberfeld says …

For over two decades, research has shown a direct correlation between the emotional maturity of officers and their problem-solving capacity. Yet, as if deliberately ignoring the scientific research finding, most police departments in the United States continue to recruit and select their officers at the very young ages of 19 or 20.

Instead, we should be hiring older officers and putting them through a standardized, mandatory curriculum of training for all our law enforcement agencies. This training must cover a minimum number of hours that will approximate, at the very least, a two-year college degree. Don’t we owe it to our communities to give the officers we charge with guarding our lives at least as many hours of training as beauticians and hairdressers?”

(Maria (Maki) Haberfeld. “Police recruits are too young, not well enough educated.” San Francisco Gate. July 29, 2016.)

Still, Haberfeld said it would be difficult to institute any additional rules governing exactly how and when officers use deadly force since the situations are very complex. "(An officer's) primary focus is on someone else’s life or (their) life is in danger," Haberfeld said. "(There's) never enough time to asses properly what’s happening around you."

"(There is) tremendous stress that impacts the way officers see things, perceive things," Haberfeld said, adding that the NYPD could teach additional coping mechanisms to help officers deal with the daily strains of the job.

"We don’t give police officers any stress management training," she said. "This is exactly where we are paying the price.”

Conclusion

No one can imagine the killing of Valentina Orellana-Peralta, an innocent victim of police shooting. No one can imagine the pain felt by her family or the loss to Valentina's community. We can help insure her tragic death is not in vain.

Whether those in charge label the death as accidental or as an unfortunate but reasonable outcome of necessary deadly force to stop a criminal, we must take steps to prevent such a tragedy – one that happens far too much – from occurring again.

Limiting the shooting of innocents is within our power to control. No one expects every death to be avoided; however, just consider the lives that would be saved if better policing practices were initiated. In no way am I advocating putting officers at greater risk. I believe they are in dangerous straits already. I simply want to address the issue to create a better educated and more talented force.

Being a police officer today is a noble profession. I hope not one more of them has to live with the guilt of shooting an innocent civilian. These are tragedies that cause lifelong scars in the people and in the institutions of our nation. God bless a new and wiser direction that stops needless loss.


TEARS OF A COP
Author Unknown


I have been where you fear to be.
I have seen what you fear to see.
I have done what you fear to do.
All these things I've done for you.

I am the one you lean upon.
The one you cast your scorn upon.
The one you bring your troubles to,
All these people I've been for you.

The one you ask to stand apart.
The one you feel should have no heart.
The one you call the officer in blue.
But I am human, just like you.

And through the years I've come to see
That I am not what you ask of me.
So take this badge and take this gun.
Will you take it? Will anyone?

And when you watch a person die,
And hear a battered baby cry.
Then so you think that you can be
All those things you ask of me?

 



Saturday, December 25, 2021

The Whitest White -- Life-Giving Paint and Natural Designs

 

                                                                                 Juno

To Electra.

A poem by Robert Herrick (1591-1674)

More white than whitest lilies far,
Or snow, or whitest swans you are:
More white than are the whitest creams,
Or moonlight tinselling the streams:
More white than pearls, or Juno's thigh,
Or Pelops' arm of ivory.
True, I confess, such whites as these
May me delight, not fully please;
Till like Ixion's cloud you be
White, warm, and soft to lie with me.

Notes:

Juno, in marble sculpture:

In Roman religion, Juno was the chief goddess and female counterpart of Jupiter, closely resembling the Greek Hera, with whom she was identified. With Jupiter and Minerva, she was a member of the Capitoline triad of deities traditionally introduced by the Etruscan kings.

Greek mythology. Pelops:

Pelops' father was Tantalus, king at Mount Sipylus in Anatolia. Wanting to make an offering to the Olympians, Tantalus cut Pelops into pieces and made his flesh into a stew, then served it to the gods. Demeter, deep in grief after the abduction of her daughter Persephone by Hades, absentmindedly accepted the offering and ate the left shoulder. The other gods sensed the plot, however, and held off from eating of the boy's body. While Tantalus was banished to Tartarus, Pelops was ritually reassembled and brought back to life, his shoulder replaced with one of ivory made for him by Hephaestus.

Greek mythology: Ixion's cloud:

Ixion was the son either of the god Ares or of Phlegyas, king of the Lapiths in Thessaly. He murdered his father-in-law and could find no one to purify him until Zeus did so and admitted him as a guest to Olympus. Ixion abused his pardon by trying to seduce Zeus’s wife, Hera. Zeus substituted for her a cloud, by which Ixion became the father of Centaurus, who fathered the Centaurs by the mares of Mount Pelion. Zeus, to punish him, bound him on a fiery wheel, which rolled unceasingly through the air or, according to the more common tradition, in the underworld. 


                            Ixion Embracing the Cloud, Carlo Maratta (1625-1713).

To Electra” is one of many poems Herrick wrote to a woman he calls “Electra,” whose appearance he compares, in another poem, to “broad day throughout the east.” What is the whitest white? Marble, ivory, a cloud, or something else? A new discovery may help answer that age old question.

Scientists at Purdue University in Indiana say they’ve created a new paint that’s so ultra-white, it could do away with the need for air conditioning – while helping to fight climate change. The white paint can keep surfaces up to 18 degrees Fahrenheit cooler than their ambient surroundings – almost like a refrigerator does, but without consuming energy.

(Xiangyu Li, Joseph Peoples, Zhifeng Huang, Zixuan Zhao, Jun Qiu, and Xiulin Ruan. “Full Daytime Sub-ambient Radiative Cooling in Commercial-like Paints with High Figure of Merit.” Purdue University News. October 21, 2020.)

According to the researchers, the paint would replace the need for air conditioning by absorbing nearly no solar energy and sending heat away from the building. Without the building heating up, air conditioning wouldn’t have to kick on.

This paint could help solve climate change and literally make a better and safer world. With global temperatures rising, more and more people are relying on cooling to stay safe and comfortable. The International Energy Agency projects that energy demand from air conditioners will triple by 2050 – equivalent to adding 10 new air conditioners every second for the next 30 years.

(Victoria Masterson. “How ultra-white paint could help fight climate change.” World Economic Forum. April 27, 2021.)

The power needed to keep air conditioners and electric fans running accounts for 20% of global electricity use, according to the IEA’s Future of Cooling report.

If you were to use this paint to cover a roof area of about 1,000 square feet, we estimate that you could get a cooling power of 10 kilowatts,” said Xiulin Ruan, a Purdue professor of mechanical engineering and one of the study’s co-authors. “That’s more powerful than the central air conditioners used by most houses.”

According to the researchers’ cost estimates, this paint would be both cheaper to produce than its commercial alternative and could save about a dollar per day that would have been spent on air conditioning for a one-story house of approximately 1,076 square feet.

(Victoria Masterson. “How ultra-white paint could help fight climate change.” World Economic Forum. April 27, 2021.)

Typical commercial white “heat rejecting paints” get warmer rather than cooler. Purdue says its product repels infrared heat from a surface and reflects up to 98.1% of sunlight. This outperforms 80%-90% of comparable products and beats the 95.5% of sunlight reflected by the researchers’ previous ultra-white paint.

In an outdoor demonstration, the team showed the paint was able to keep surfaces 19° Fahrenheit (10.5C) cooler than the ambient surroundings at night. It can also cool surfaces by 8° Fahrenheit (4.4C) under strong sunlight during noon hours.

What Makes the Paint “Whiter Than White”?

Since the paint is very reflective it also resulted in being really white. The researchers explained that there is a very high concentration of barium sulfate, a chemical that is used in photo paper and cosmetics. There are different particle sizes of barium sulfate in the paint and the wider range of sizes help scatter more of the light spectrum from the sun.

Although painting walls and roofs white to deflect heat has been done for centuries, since the 1970s, scientists have attempted to develop radiative cooling paint as a workable alternative to traditional air conditioners. This new paint is the result of six years of research.

It’s very counterintuitive for a surface in direct sunlight to be cooler than the temperature your local weather station reports for that area, but we’ve shown this to be possible,” said Ruan.

Do you want proof already in practice? In Los Angeles, California, some streets and pavements have been painted with a white coating called CoolSeal to help reduce temperatures in the city. This resulted in the streets being 10 to 15 degrees Fahrenheit (5.5C - 8.3C) cooler on average than others, according to the city’s Bureau of Street Services.

Where would the heat go? Scientists say the paint would not only send heat away from a surface, but also away from Earth into deep space where heat travels indefinitely at the speed of light. This way, heat doesn’t get trapped within the atmosphere and contribute to global warming.

We’re not moving heat from the surface to the atmosphere. We’re just dumping it all out into the universe, which is an infinite heat sink,” said Xiangyu Li, a postdoctoral researcher at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology who worked on this project as a Ph.D. student in Ruan’s lab.

Earth’s surface would actually get cooler with this technology if the paint were applied to a variety of surfaces including roads, rooftops and cars all over the world, the researchers said.

Your air conditioning kicks on mainly due to sunlight heating up the roof and walls and making the inside of your house feel warmer. This paint is basically creating free air conditioning by reflecting that sunlight and offsetting those heat gains from inside your house,” said Joseph Peoples, a Purdue Ph.D. student in mechanical engineering and a co-author of the work.

This study was supported by the Cooling Technologies Research Center at Purdue University and the Air Force Office of Scientific Research through the Defense University Research Instrumentation Program (grant no. FA9550-17-1-0368).

(Xiangyu Li, Joseph Peoples, Zhifeng Huang, Zixuan Zhao, Jun Qiu,  and Xiulin Ruan. “Full Daytime Sub-ambient Radiative Cooling in Commercial-like Paints with High Figure of Merit.” Purdue University News. October 21, 2020.)

Implications

Can you imagine that something as simple as a new whiter-than-white paint could benefit the human race so much?

Creating cool roofs also has the added benefit of reducing the amount of water used for irrigation in cities. Based on regional climate simulations of 18 California counties, Berkeley Lab researchers Pouya Vahmani and Andrew Jones found that widespread cool roof adoption could reduce outdoor water consumption by as much as 9 percent.

You might not do cool roofs just to save water, but it’s another previously unrecognized benefit of having cool roofs. And from a water management standpoint, it’s an entirely different way of thinking – to manipulate the local climate in order to manipulate water demand.”

    (Pouya Vahmani & Andrew D. Jones. “Water conservation benefits of urban heat mitigation.” Nature Communications volume 8, Article number: 1072. 2017.)

Using statistical modeling, the researchers estimated that their ultra-white paint could reduce air conditioning use by up to 70 percent in hot cities like Reno, Nevada, and Phoenix, Arizona. In a rather extreme model, they also found that covering 0.5 to 1 percent of the Earth’s surface—buildings, roads, unused land, just about everything—with the ultra-white paint would be enough to stop the global warming trend.

It’s a lot of area, but if one day we need to use this approach to help reverse the warming trend, it’s still affordable—the paint is not expensive,” said Ruan.

(Sarah Kuta. “This Ultra-White Paint May Someday Replace Air Conditioning.” Smithsonian. April 21, 2021.)

The researchers have applied for a patent, and they’re doing additional testing to understand the paint’s long-term durability and reliability outdoors as they work toward making the paint available to consumers. They haven’t yet determined an exact price for the paint, but Ruan says he expects the paint to be similar to those on the market now – roughly $30 to $40 per gallon.

Remarkable.

Yet, there is always a price to pay. In this case, it is also a natural cost.

On the flip side, digging up raw barite ore to produce and process the barium sulphite that makes up nearly 60% of the paint means it has a huge carbon footprint. And using the paint widely would mean a dramatic increase in the mining of barium.

But take heart, folks. Andrew Parnell, research fellow in physics and astronomy at the University of Sheffield, says barium sulphite-based paint is just one way to improve the reflectivity of buildings. Nature may provide us with other useful techniques. Parnell explains …

The wings of one intensely white beetle species called Lepidiota stigma appear a strikingly bright white thanks to nanostructures in their scales, which are very good at scattering incoming light. This natural light-scattering property can be used to design even better paints: for example, by using recycled plastic to create white paint containing similar nanostructures with a far lower carbon footprint. When it comes to taking inspiration from nature, the sky’s the limit.”

(Andrew Parnell. “The World’s New ‘Whitest’ Paint Has a Darker Side.” Science: The Wire. September 22, 2021.)

Humankind may discover some design in nature to help save itself from destruction. God provides such miraculous remedies, and scientists discover their restorative powers seemingly every day.

To close, white is symbolic as we all know. Another poem comes to mind. In 1922, Robert Frost described a simple scene from nature in a poem – a spider on a flower (known as a heal-all) is holding a moth that it has captured as its prey. But Frost's description is filled with gothic imagery, including the fact that all three elements – the spider, the flower and the moth – are white, which here seems to embody, not purity and goodness, but deathly pallor. Ironically, it serves to remind us that nature has a larger design.

Frost was known for this kind of thing. Here is what a Time magazine article, titled "Books: The Poet Laureate (Robert Frost)" said about him in 1962:

"Many of his poems are half wisdom and half whimsy, and Frost often seems to be sharing a sly, private joke with God. In fact, one couplet in In the Clearing (poetry collection) offers God a bargain: 'Forgive, 0 Lord, my little jokes on Thee And I'll forgive Thy great big one on me.'"

The whitest white – arms of ivory, thighs of marble, paint, beetles, and spiders. We still have a lot to learn as we walk toward the light and seek the true designs that govern our pale existence.

Design

by Robert Frost

I found a dimpled spider, fat and white,
On a white heal-all, holding up a moth
Like a white piece of rigid satin cloth—
Assorted characters of death and blight
Mixed ready to begin the morning right,
Like the ingredients of a witches’ broth—
A snow-drop spider, a flower like a froth,
And dead wings carried like a paper kite.

What had that flower to do with being white,
The wayside blue and innocent heal-all?
What brought the kindred spider to that height,
Then steered the white moth thither in the night?
What but design of darkness to appall?--
If design govern in a thing so small.

Postscript “Spiritual White”

The shrapnel entered through the armhole of Steve Price’s bulletproof vest just as he was firing his rifle, and a mortar fragment pierced his lung. When the medics finally reached him, they airlifted the 24-year-old Marine from the Vietnamese jungle to a military hospital in the Philippines for surgery.

Doctor Greyson, said, “The burly, heavily tattooed, self-described schoolyard bully became tearful when he described to me what happened during the operation.”

Here is what Steve Price said:

'Suddenly I realized I was up near the ceiling, looking down at my body. A brilliant white light embraced and encompassed me. It took me in. I felt such warmth and peace and was bathed in the most peaceful, joyous feeling imaginable.

I found myself in a place like the Garden of Eden. I didn’t say the word God for a long time, but now I can say that the light was God. It was like the most loving mother embracing her infant, only a million times more than that. On the other side of a stream bubbling through the garden was my long-dead grand­father. I went to move toward him, but it was over.'”

(Bruce Greyson, M.D. “A Doctor’s Surprising Findings on Near-Death Experiences.” Saturday Evening Post. December 13, 2021.)